Well, of course I need more comics!
Jul. 28th, 2004 05:43 pmSo I'm considering adding yet more titles to my pull-box. (How many am I already reading? Er... don't ask. Even I don't actually want to know.)
If you're reading any of these, and have any thoughts about them one way or another, do please share.
CATWOMAN (#33)
I haven't been reading Selina's title, though I don't dislike hermuch and I enjoy Ed Brubaker's scripting as much as any sane person. The solicits for this month's, though, make me wonder how closely CATWOMAN is going to tie-in with the other Gotham titles for "War Games," and whether I should be reading it for the duration.
JUSTICE LEAGUE ELITE (maxiseries)
Okay, I don't read JLA, so I don't know the setup or background or whatever. The two characters joining the JLE who I already know, I like (Ollie and Wally, and I'm reading both their titles at the moment), and several of the ones I know barely anything about intrigue me already... but, well, being as it's a spinoff from JLA, I'm worried that JLE will be more of the bad crack.
THE LEGION (#35-38)
On the one hand, I adore Gail Simone. On the other hand, I wouldn't know the Legion from X-Force if I ran into them in broad daylight and they were wearing nametags. Is this storyling going to be accessible to me without massive back-issue supplementation?
THE MONOLITH (#6-8)
Bruce and Babs are guesting in this storyline, or at least the first issue of the arc, according to DC. Er... what's this title about?
If you're reading any of these, and have any thoughts about them one way or another, do please share.
CATWOMAN (#33)
I haven't been reading Selina's title, though I don't dislike her
JUSTICE LEAGUE ELITE (maxiseries)
Okay, I don't read JLA, so I don't know the setup or background or whatever. The two characters joining the JLE who I already know, I like (Ollie and Wally, and I'm reading both their titles at the moment), and several of the ones I know barely anything about intrigue me already... but, well, being as it's a spinoff from JLA, I'm worried that JLE will be more of the bad crack.
THE LEGION (#35-38)
On the one hand, I adore Gail Simone. On the other hand, I wouldn't know the Legion from X-Force if I ran into them in broad daylight and they were wearing nametags. Is this storyling going to be accessible to me without massive back-issue supplementation?
THE MONOLITH (#6-8)
Bruce and Babs are guesting in this storyline, or at least the first issue of the arc, according to DC. Er... what's this title about?
Again, late reply to a LJ comment. Beat me with a spoon...
Date: 2004-08-01 11:00 am (UTC)I've got a long and complicated history with the original Catwoman series, and mostly it's bad thanks to run-ins I've had with Chris Dee and her 'Cat-Tails' bunch. I thought the older series was pretty fluffy and is a prime example of early-90s substance-free, violent and silly comic book writing. That's not to say that sort of format is without its charms, but I'd rather see my heroes as mature, grounded, realistic characters rather than globe-trotting cuthroats.
I thought the old series did a real injustice to Selina Kyle's character, particularily after the Year-One style 'Her Sister's Keeper', which started the series off with a lot of potential but crashed and burned with Chuck Dixon. It was always puzzling to me why they chose to turn Catwoman away from her Miller-esqure roots of prostitution and redemption through violence (a journey that so closely mirrors Batman's that it becomes a commentary on gender and class in the DCU) and make her into a female James Bond who steals.
I guess it's mostly a matter of taste, although I don't think the title was particularily well-written under Dixon or Grayson. But the whole thing is just...silly, especially in comparison to the gravity and depth lent to the character by Brubaker's work. Catwoman got her soul under Brubaker; with Dixon, Grayson et al, she a cypher.
Anyway, sorry, long response to a short question.